Unai Emery vs Eddie Howe as ex-Bournemouth boss remains in Newcastle manager race but Europa League winner pulls out

EXPERIENCED European winner or fresh face with fresh ideas?

That was the dilemma on the minds of the new-look boardroom at St James' Park in their attempts to appoint a new manager.

Plenty of big names have been linked with the vacant post – Antonio Conte, Joachim Low and Xavi are among those to reject the Toon's advances.

And it looked as though it would be a straight shootout between Unai Emery and Eddie Howe before the Villarreal boss ruled himself out of the running.

Now Howe appears to have a free run at the Toon gig – if he wants it.

So how do the two match up as managers?

Howe, 44 later in November, is six years younger than Emery who turned 50 today.

And those bonus years of experience mean the Spaniard has managed more than 300 extra matches compared to his English counterpart – 871 to 545.


For Emery, those are spread across eight different club jobs – Lorca Deportiva, Almeria, Valencia, Spartak Moscow, Sevilla, Paris Saint-Germain, Arsenal and now Villarreal.

He has won 463, drawn 196 and lost 212, equating to a win percentage of 53 per cent – that includes a 25-13-13 record in the Premier League with the Gunners at 49 per cent.

And, the silverware speaks for itself.

Emery is the master of the Europa League – winning it three times with Sevilla and then again with Villarreal last season.

He also picked up the Ligue 1 title, two Coupes de la Ligue and two Coupes de France during his spell with PSG.

But despite his proven, pragmatic success, the former midfielder has often been criticised for his style of play and management, especially during a difficult patch at Arsenal succeeding Arsene Wenger.


Howe, meanwhile, has had just three managerial jobs – and two of those were at Bournemouth, taking them from League Two to the Premier League.

His other spell was a stint at Burnley between 2011 and 2012.

The ex-defender's 545 matches can be broken down into 228 victories, 114 draws and 203 defeats at a 42 per cent win rate.

That includes 56, 43 and 91 respectively in his five seasons in the English top flight at 29 per cent before resignation upon relegation in 2020.

Three of those 91 defeats were against Emery – going down 2-1, 5-1 and 1-0 in their meetings.

Howe earned League Two promotion in 2010 and then got the Cherries out of League One in 2013.

Two years later, he lifted his only trophy to date, the EFL Championship crown as Bournemouth.

But if he does take the job to replace Steve Bruce, he will be hoping there is no need to repeat that achievement.

Newcastle currently sit 19th in the Premier League with no wins and just four points from ten games, already six adrift of safety.

Read our Football news live blog for the very latest rumours, gossip and done deals

    Source: Read Full Article